Defensive lineman Sean Brewer is the only SCAC player to be named a three-time all-American. The league's Defensive Player-of-the-Year in 1991 and 1992, Brewer posted 435 tackles which ranks fourth in SCAC history. He also had a school-record 53 sacks in his four-year career for the Majors which included a single-season school record 15 sacks in 1991.

Running backs Kelvin Gladney and Mike McKenzie were both recognized for their offensive production. Gladney, the league's Offensive Player-of-the-Year in 1993 and 1994, posted the most prolific rushing season in SCAC history with 1,882 yards in 1994 - capped by an all-America selection. Gladney averaged 162.4 yards per game in his two years in Jackson (tops in league history) and ranks fifth in league history for both career rushing yards (3,085) and touchdowns scored (40).

McKenzie rushed for 3,003 yards in his career and is one of just six players in league history to eclipse the 3,000-yard plateau. He owns the Millsaps record for career rushing attempts with 665.

Wide receiver Mike Ingram. Ingram is sixth on the league's all-time yards receiving list with 2,352, which is second all-time at Millsaps. The four-time all-SCAC performer caught 159 balls for 20 touchdowns.

Offensive lineman Matt Huard was named First Team all-SCAC as both a junior and senior and the Majors finished second in the league in scoring offense both seasons. In 1996, he spearheaded a Millsaps line that opened holes for the league's leading rusher, Brad Madden.

George Lumm and Matt O'Bryant represent two-fifths of the linebacker selections. Lumm ranks 11th on the SCAC career tackles list with 370, including a league-leading 119 in 1998. A four-time all-SCAC honoree, Lumm finished his career with 6.5 sacks and was a freshman on the last Millsaps team to win a SCAC championship (1996).

O'Bryant is the league's leading tackler in the SCAC era with 462. The two-time SCAC Defensive Player-of-the-Year (2001, 2002) and four-time First Team selection led the league in tackles per game three times and finished second once. He set the league's single-season record for fumble recoveries with six in 2003.