| 1971 |
James Avery Holder |
| 1972 |
David Ronald McCollum |
| 1973 |
Robert Douglas Carter |
| 1974 |
Florence Jo Smith |
| 1975 |
George Stennis Watson |
| 1976 |
Joseph Tillman Reiff |
| 1977 |
James Minor Matheny (chosen, though award not obtained from ABS) |
| 1978 |
James Crawford Ray |
| 1981 |
Mervyn Jonathan Altman; William John Singer, Jr. |
| 1982 |
Susan Lee Woodward |
| 1983 |
Elizabeth Milazzo |
| 1984 |
Marilyn Diener |
| 1986 |
Mary Theresa Woodward |
| 1987 |
Dianne P. Harms |
| 1992 |
Rachel Furner |
| 1993 |
Aileen Yelle |
| 1996 |
Howard Y. Pickett |
| 1997 |
Elizabeth Young |
| 1999 |
Margus Sarglepp |
| 2000 |
Mark Anthony Salvaggio |
| 1993 |
Heather Hensarling |
| 1994 |
Cynthia Dee Weems |
| 1995 |
Albert Deon Mosley |
| 1997 |
Lamar Kirk Mitchell |
| 1998 |
Michael Barham |
| 1999 |
Andrea Kersh Johnson |
| 2000 |
Martha Louise Ostenrude |
| 2003 |
James Barrett Ingram |
| 2004 |
George Richard James |
| 2005 |
Jacob Dale Wilson |
| 2006 |
William Bradford Corban; Theon Lemure Johnson III |
| 2009 |
Candice L. Fisher |
| 2005 |
Matthew Hunter Marston |
| 2006 |
Khyati Gupta |
| 2007 |
Jessica Lee Hoffpauir |
| 2008 |
Kathryn Danielle Cook; Thomas Brown Richardson |
| 2009 |
Thomas Alexander Allain |
| 1994 |
Howard Y. Pickett, “Beyond Intoxication in the Mysticism of al-Hallaj” |
| 1996 |
Elizabeth Young, "Encountering the Text: Ceremony" |
| 1997 |
Charles Lee Duval II |
| 1998 |
Andrea Kersh Johnson, “Augustine, Luther and Schleiermacher: Sin and Human Identity” |
| 1999 |
Drew Carraway Walker |
| 2001 |
Drew Carraway Walker |
| 2003 |
Judith Claire Coleman, “Truth in Negation: A Positive Reading of Deconstructive A/Theology” |
| 2004 |
Jason Michael Bronson, “Ethics, Literature, History, and War: Evil Everywhere” |
| 2005 |
Stacey Elizabeth Douglas, “The Mystical Qualities in the Song of Songs” |
| 2006 |
Belinda Barrios Rives, “A Model for All? Religious and Sexual Identity Integration in Homosexual Persons” |
| 2007 |
Thomas Brown Richardson, “Fitting In: The Women of Matthew's Genealogy of Jesus in Relation to the Gospel” |
| 2008 |
Thomas Brown Richardson, “From Indefinable to Immortal: Death and Afterlife's Influence on Eastern Traditions” |
| 2009 |
Brittany Elise Hickman, “Lost in Translation: The Chinese Rites Controversy” |
